Leadership Is a Different Skill Set

Why being great at what you do doesn't necessarily prepare you to lead others.

A few weeks ago, I was playing golf with a young leader of a non-profit who was frustrated with some of the changes he was trying to make at his organization.

He had ideas. Good ones, from what I could tell. He knew what he wanted to accomplish and was eager to move things forward.

The problem? People weren't exactly lining up to get on board.

As he described the resistance he was encountering, I told him something that I think surprised him a little:

"This is the work."

The resistance, the difficult conversations, the people who don't see things the way you do. That's not an obstacle standing between you and the real work of leadership.

That is the work.

Expertise Doesn't Automatically Translate to Leadership

My friend is a smart guy. He's knowledgeable about his industry, committed to his work, and genuinely wants to make a difference.

But knowing your field and knowing how to lead an organization are two very different things.

And this isn't unique to churches.

I've seen the same dynamic play out in businesses, nonprofits, and organizations of all sizes.

Someone excels in their area of expertise. They're promoted, appointed, or otherwise find themselves responsible for leading a team or an organization.

Suddenly, the skills that made them successful aren't quite enough.

They know how to solve problems, but now they need to help other people solve them. They know what needs to change, but they need to bring others along. They have a clear vision, but getting people to share it is another matter entirely.

And unlike technical expertise, leadership rarely comes with a straightforward set of instructions.

You Can't Just Be Right

One of the things we talked about on the golf course was trust.

My friend was understandably focused on what needed to change. But we spent some time talking about how he was approaching the people he needed to help make those changes happen.

Because here's the thing: Having the right answer doesn't mean people will follow you.

You can have a brilliant strategy, a compelling vision, and a perfectly reasonable plan. But if people don't trust you, don't feel heard, or don't understand why the change matters, you're going to have a hard time getting anywhere.

And sometimes, the harder you push, the more resistance you create.

That's a difficult adjustment for people who are accustomed to being rewarded for their expertise.

Leadership requires a different kind of work. Listening when you'd rather explain. Asking questions when you're certain you know the answer. Recognizing that people aren't simply obstacles to overcome on the way to your goal.

It also requires accepting that you can't control how everyone responds.

You can influence, guide, support, and challenge people. But you can't make them embrace change just because you've decided it's the right thing to do.

The Value of Someone Outside the Situation

As we continued talking, I found myself doing something familiar.

I was asking questions, challenging a few assumptions, and suggesting different ways he might approach the situation.

It was essentially the same kind of conversation I have with executives and organizational leaders in my consulting work.

And it reminded me that the challenges leaders face aren't necessarily determined by their title, industry, or the size of their organization.

A nonprofit director, a religious leader, a department head, and a CEO might operate in very different environments. But they can all find themselves asking similar questions:

  • How do I get people on board with a change I believe is important?

  • Why isn't my approach working?

  • Am I missing something?

Sometimes, what a leader needs most isn't another framework or a more detailed plan, it's someone who can help them think through what's happening. Someone with enough experience to recognize patterns, enough distance to see things differently, and enough independence to tell them when their own approach might be part of the problem.

Not someone who simply validates their thinking.

Someone who helps them think better.

Leadership Is Something You Keep Learning

I don't think anyone reaches a point where they've completely figured out leadership.

The circumstances change, the people change, the challenges change, and what worked in one situation might not work in the next. That's part of what makes leadership both difficult and interesting.

My friend isn't struggling because he's incapable of leading – he's encountering the part of leadership that can't be mastered through subject-matter expertise alone.

And the fact that he's willing to talk through those challenges, question his approach, and consider doing things differently is a pretty good place to start.

Because the goal isn't to become the leader who never encounters resistance, it's to become the leader who knows how to work through it.

That's the work.